Additional menu

Top 10 fish oil supplements (2023 update)

Last updated: October 26, 2022

Fish oil is the most commonly prescribed supplement in the world, for good reason: the omega-3 fatty acids found in fish oil pills have profound effects on heart health and cognitive function.

The omega 3 fatty acids found in fish oil pills exert a potent anti-inflammatory effect on your body, and have been shown to improve blood triglycerides (an important risk factor for cardiovascular disease) and boost your mood and cognitive function as well.

Our research team reviewed and ranked the best fish oil supplements on the market, plus went in-depth on the latest science behind the potential health benefits of fish oil.

Why You Should Trust Us

    Our advisory panel and our research team rank the best health products and supplements based on performance, label accuracy, and the efficacy of the ingredients in the products.

At A Glance
our top picks for fish oil supplements
  1. Best Overall: Omegawell by Live Conscious
  2. Best for older adults: Optima Omega-3 by Nuzena
  3. Best for heart health: Viva Labs Ultra Strength Fish Oil
  4. Best for women: Nature’s Branch Triple Strength Fish Oil
  5. The Vitamin Shoppe Omega-3 Fish Oil

Rankings

Last updated: October 18, 2022
Fish oil supplements considered: 29
Hours of research: 57
Experts reviewed: 13
Scientific papers referenced: 26

IMAGE PRODUCT
1. Omegawell by Live Conscious
  • One of the better daily habits you can have
  • No filler “additives”, all-natural
  • Made in the USA in an FDA-approved facility
View Latest Price →
2. Optima Omega-3 by Nuzena
  • It stands out as one of the better omega-3 and fish oil formulas
  • It is tested monthly for mercury levels and potency
  • A no-nonsense top-3 option and one of the cheapest options
View Latest Price →
3. Viva Labs Ultra Strength Fish Oil
  • Each capsule provides a full 1000 mg of omega 3 fatty acids
  • Provides 705 mg and 245 mg of EPA and DHA
  • Super-minimalist formulation (no flavors, no additives)
View on Amazon →
4. Nature’s Branch Triple Strength Fish Oil
  • Each softgel has 720 mg of fish oil, 432 mg of EPA, and 288 mg of DHA
  • It has a natural lemon flavoring
  • Best for people who don’t like the smell of pure, unflavored fish oil
View on Amazon →
5. The Vitamin Shoppe Omega-3 Fish Oil
  • 1000 mg of fish oil
  • 300 mg of EPA and 200 mg of DHA per capsule
  • Super-high dosage but decent choice thanks to its pure formulation
View on Amazon →
6. OmegaVia Fish Oil
  • Focused on delivering an extraordinarily high concentration of EPA and DHA
  • It compounds over 95% of the omega-3 fatty acid content in the supplement
  • The mercury and PCB levels are extremely low thanks to regular purity testing
View on Amazon →
7. Dr. Tobias Optimum Omega 3 Fish Oil
  • 2000 mg of fish oil
  • 800 mg of EPA and 600 mg of DHA per capsule
  • The purity and quality of the ingredients are great
View on Amazon →
8. Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega D3
  • 325 mg of EPA and 225 mg of DHA per capsule
  • The fish oil comes from deep sea fish (anchovies and sardines)
  • Tested for toxin contents
View on Amazon →
9. WHC UnoCardio 1000+
  • 670 mg of EPA and 395 mg of DHA per capsule
  • Sourcing: wild-caught sardine, herring, mackerel, and anchovy
  • It has vitamin D to boost mood and immune function
View on Amazon →
10. Nature’s Bounty Fish Oil
  • Each softgel provides 750 mg of omega 3 fatty acids
  • 435 mg are EPA and 240 mg are DHA
  • Easy to take
View on Amazon →

1. Omegawell by Live Conscious

Check the lowest price

For those who’re serious about ending crippling joint pain, Omegawell by Live Conscious is the best you can get.

No other fish oil can compete with the patented complex of 800 EPA and 600 DHA.

What does this mean for a fish oil supplement?

Well, everything.

EPA and DHA are the crucial macronutrients inside fish oil that help the heart, joint, brain, organ tissue, and immune system. Among all the fatty acids, EPA and DHA are the most potent.

From alleviating joint pain to providing your body more energy and focus, Omegawell is one of the better daily habits you can have in the supplement space.

No filler “additives.” All natural, and made in the USA in an FDA-approved facility.

The all-around fish oil winner of 2023.

Check the lowest price

2. Optima Omega-3 by Nuzena

Click here for the lowest price

Nuzena is a brand-new supplement company known for their no-nonsense formulas.

Nuzena’s Optima Omega-3 “formula” stands out as one of better omega-3 and fish oil formulas. Some of the other fish oils on this list have higher EPA/DHA levels, but are twice as expensive and/or not as high in quality.

(Nuzena gets their stuff tested monthly for mercury levels, potency, etc., so you know it’s a quality product).

The result?

Better skin. Better well-being. Better joints and flexibility.

A no-nonsense top-3 option and one of the cheapest options, too.

3.  Viva Labs Ultra Strength Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

If you want a fish oil supplement that really packs a punch, look no further than Via Labs Ultra Strength.  Each capsule provides a full 1000 mg of omega 3 fatty acids, and 705 mg and 245 mg of EPA and DHA.

This very high omega 3 content makes it an excellent pick for raw omega 3 content, and its super-minimalist formulation (no flavors, no additives) makes it well-suited for people who appreciate clean supplement design.

4.  Nature’s Branch Triple Strength Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

Although not as powerful as our winner, Nature’s Branch is backed up by its quality.

Each softgel has 720 mg of fish oil, 432 mg of EPA, and 288 mg of DHA. It’s a high dose fish oil that’s also got natural lemon flavoring to mask some of the fishy flavor, so it’s a good choice for people who don’t like the smell of pure, unflavored fish oil.

5.  The Vitamin Shoppe Omega-3 Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

The Vitamin Shoppe’s fish oil offering is really simple, but the dosage of the most impactful compounds leaves a bit to be desired: it’s got 1000 mg of fish oil, but only 300 mg of EPA and 200 mg of DHA per capsule.

If a super-high dosage is less critical for you, it’s a decent choice thanks to its pure formulation.

6.  OmegaVia Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

OmegaVia focuses on delivering an extraordinarily high concentration of EPA and DHA. These super-compounds make up over 95% of the omega-3 fatty acid content in the supplement.

As you’d expect, the mercury and PCB levels are also extremely low thanks to regular purity testing. The only downside? A few too many fillers in the capsule composition. 

7.  Dr. Tobias Optimum Omega 3 Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

The overall fish oil content in Dr. Tobias Omega 3 is high, but the EPA and DHA content is only middle-of-the-road. For that reason, it wound up further down in the rankings, even though the purity and quality of the ingredients are great.

8.  Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega D3

Check price at Amazon

 Nordic Naturals has a ton of name recognition, but its formulation isn’t quite as advanced as some of its competitors. The fish oil content is good, but the EPA and DHA content (325 and 225 mg each) isn’t quite as high as our research team would like.

However, their sourcing is great: their fish oil comes from deep sea fish (anchovies and sardines), and that each batch is tested for toxin contents, so from a purity perspective, it’s great.

9.  WHC UnoCardio 1000+

Check price at Amazon

This omega 3 fish oil boasts a hefty amount of EPA and DHA—670 and 395 mg per capsule, respectively, and the sourcing is very solid too: wild-caught sardine, herring, mackerel, and anchovy.

Though other supplements beat it out on total fish oil content, it does have vitamin D to boost mood and immune function, so it’s a good niche pick for people in cold climates who don’t see much sun.

10.  Nature’s Bounty Fish Oil

Check price at Amazon

Nature’s Bounty is a common sight at brick and mortar pharmacies. How does it hold up?

Dosage-wise, it’s good but not great.  Each softgel provides 750 mg of omega 3 fatty acids; of these, 435 mg are EPA and 240 mg are DHA.  Compared to other competitors, it loses out when it comes to total fish oil content.

Category winners

Best fish oil overall: Omegawell by Live Conscious

Omegawell by Live Conscious is pure, high-dosage, and free of extraneous ingredients. What more can you want in a fish oil supplement? If you want an all-around winner, this should be your go-to choice. 

Best fish oil for older adults: Optima Omega-3 by Nuzena

Optima Omega-3 is strict, simple, and tested for purity. That’s great news for older adults, who also benefit from the additional flexibility in dosage provided by Nuzena’s 430/290 EPA/DHA capsules.

Best fish oil for women: Nature’s Branch Triple Strength Fish Oil

Nature’s Branch Triple Strength Fish Oil is great for women, because Nature’s Branch puts a particular focus on purity. Thanks to third party testing, it’s certified free of potential contaminants like mercury, PCBs, and dioxins—great news for all women, but especially for women who are pregnant. 

Best fish oil for cognitive health: Omegawell by Live Conscious

Omegawell is great for cognitive health because of its nearly 1:1 ratio of EPA and DHA, both of which are vital for cognitive function. Add to that independently-verified purity and you’ve got a big winner for brain function. 

Best fish oil for heart health: Viva Labs Ultra Strength Fish Oil

When it comes to heart health, the latest research suggests that getting a high dosage of DHA and EPA is critical. That’s why Viva Labs is our pick for cardiovascular health:  its DHA and EPA content per capsule are at the front of the pack.

Best fish oil for athletes: Omegawell by Live Conscious

In addition to its cardiovascular and cognitive health benefits, fish oil sees increasing use among athletes who want to take advantage of its anti-inflammatory properties for pain and inflammation. The even balance of EPA and DHA in Omegawell is the perfect choice for this use-case.

Who should buy fish oil?

Fish oil is one of the most versatile supplements out there: it’s got solid evidence supporting its use for everything from heart health to mental health to joint inflammation. Here are the major categories of people who should consider a fish oil supplement:

People who want to improve their heart health: Fish oil’s most heavily-studied application is reducing cardiovascular disease risk. The omega-3s in fish oil has been shown to improve blood triglycerides and decrease blood pressure, both of which are major risk factors for heart disease (1).

Older adults who want to preserve cognitive function: The anti-inflammatory properties of fish oil have made it the target of researchers looking to slow or prevent cognitive decline in older adults, and research suggests that people who take fish oil preserve both brain size and brain function better as they age (2).

People who want to combat depression and anxiety: One of the most exciting but least-publicized benefits of omega-3 fatty acids are their ability to improve both depression and anxiety. The scientific evidence supporting both of these applications is shockingly robust (3,4), so if mental wellbeing is a goal for you, fish oil should be in your supplement stack.

People who want to cut down on inflammation: inflammation in the body contributes to problems ranging from obesity to joint pain to vascular disease. Fish oil’s anti-inflammatory properties are well-documented, making it a versatile supplement for cutting down on systemic inflammation.

How we ranked

Given the popularity of fish oil, we started with a huge pool of products, so we applied a string of strict criteria for identifying high-quality products.

Good manufacturing and independently-verified purity: First off, we wanted to check that fish oil products weren’t contaminated with heavy metals, dioxins, PCBs, or other contamination?

These contaminants tend to accumulate in fish in much higher concentrations than are found in ocean water naturally, so it’s critical to verify that our top fish oil products were screened for these pollutants.

This eliminated some high-profile brands like Puritan’s Pride and Kirkland Signature, since third-party testing found these products contained more contaminants than their competitors.

High per-capsule dose of omega-3 fatty acids: Some companies play tricks with their dosage by quoting the fish oil or omega-3 content of one “serving,” meaning two or three capsules. To level the playing field, we compared dosage on a per-capsule basis.

We looked not just at fish oil content, but at total omega-3 fatty acid content. Some lower-quality brands like GNC Fish Oil had good fish oil content but only middling omega-3 fatty acid content, so they got axed.

A high fraction of EPA and DHA: Emerging research suggests that the biggest factor affecting the efficacy of a fish oil supplement is its EPA and DHA content.

(EPA and DHA stand for eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid, two key components in fish oil).

Based on this evidence, we rated supplements higher if a high fraction of their total omega-3 content was made up of EPA and DHA. This propelled products like Viva Labs and Omegawell high up in the rankings, thanks to their incredibly potent formulations.

Quality sourcing: Lastly, we paid close attention to where the fish oil came from. Better-quality fish oil comes from wild-caught fish, not farm-raised fish, so we rewarded products with specific sourcing information.

FAQ

Q: What is fish oil good for?

A: Fish oil can reduce blood pressure and the concentration of harmful triglycerides in the blood (which are both great for heart health).

Fish oil is also a powerful anti-inflammatory, helping it fight everything from joint pain to cognitive decline.

Fish oil can even improve mental wellness by reducing the symptoms of depression and anxiety, though the mechanism for this impressive feat are still unclear (5).

Q: What is fish oil?

A: Fish oil is a concentrated form of the unsaturated fats that are found in fatty fish like salmon and tuna, as well as in other marine oil sources like krill oil.

These unsaturated fats are very high in omega-3 fatty acids. While fish oil is technically just an edible oil like olive oil, the health benefits of these omega-3 fatty acids are the source of fish oil’s substantial benefits.

Even among the omega-3 fatty acids, two are by far the most important: EPA and DHA. These two molecules alone likely account for most or all of the benefit of fish oil.

Q: Does fish oil have benefits for your skin?

A: Though the potential cardiovascular and cognitive benefits of fish oil tend to steal the spotlight, fish oil has been used as a clinical treatment for psoriasis since at least the 1980s.

One study demonstrated a significant improvement in psoriasis symptoms after eight weeks of fish oil supplementation (6).

Other research has found that fish oil can actually increase the content of omega-3 fatty acid in your skin cells, which might explain the mechanism of action by which fish oil can improve skin quality (7).

Q: When should you take fish oil?

A: In the morning or in the evening are both great times to take fish oil. Fish oil is a fairly long-lasting compound, so it is typically taken in just one or two doses during the day. When you take fish oil (as in morning, afternoon, or evening) is not as important as taking it on a regular basis.

Some evidence suggests that fish oil alongside a meal that has a high fat content can help boost the absorption of EPA and DHA, so you can incorporate this strategy if you really want to maximize your omega-3 levels (8).

Q: What are EPA and DHA in fish oil?

A: EPA and DHA are acronyms for eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid—these two chemicals are specific examples of omega-3 fatty acids.

They have been studied in the most detail out of the omega-3 fatty acids (there are others, such as alpha-linolenic acid or ALA, which you can find in abundant quantities in sources like flax oil).

There is also substantial clinical evidence to support the health benefits of EPA and DHA: these compounds are so potent that purified version are under development as prescription medications to treat heart disease.

Related articles

Recap

Fish oil is an incredibly potent supplement with a wide range of benefits: heart health, cognitive function, mental wellness, and systemic inflammation.

Aim for a fish oil supplement that delivers at least one gram of omega-3 fatty acids per day, and ideally two or three grams. Try to keep the omega-3 content as high as possible, and ditto for the EPA and DHA content: some studies use doses of 0.8-2 grams of EPA+DHA, not just total fish oil.

Thanks to the wide range of potential health benefits and the excellent safety profile, fish oil is one of the best types of supplements on the market if you are looking to invest in your long-term health and wellness.

For Alpha XR‘s #1 fish oil recommendation, click here.

Avatar

John Davis

John Davis is a Minneapolis-based health and fitness writer with over 7 years of experience researching the science of high performance athletics, long-term health, nutrition, and wellness. As a trained scientist, he digs deep into the medical, nutritional, and epidemiological literature to uncover the keys to healthy living through better nutrition.
Ezoicreport this ad